Runner checking fitness tracker and workout app metrics during outdoor training

Top Fitness Apps Tested: Which Actually Build Long-Term Exercise Habits

TM
TechMinds Lab Editorial Team
Published · Updated Oct 1, 2026
🔬 Hands-on Desk Test
ⓘ TechMinds is reader-supported. We test products independently. When you purchase through links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn how we test.
Fitness AppsWorkout TrackingDigital HealthMobile AppsHabit Building

Keeping a fitness habit alive is harder than starting one. I tested four fitness apps on a daily basis for three months — Keep, Boohee Health (Mint Health), Xiaomi Mi Fitness, and Huawei Health — to answer a simple question: which one actually gets a normal person to keep moving? I am not a trainer and I do not have an iron will, so this is a realistic test, not a sponsored showcase. Spoiler: the best app is the one whose reminders you do not learn to ignore, and for me that was a Chinese-made app I had underestimated.

The apps I lived with

  • Keep (Keep fitness) — the largest Chinese fitness platform, with guided videos, running routes, and a huge free library. This is the one I kept and still open most mornings.
  • Boohee Health (Mint Health / Bohe) — a food and calorie tracker with the deepest Chinese food database. Best for anyone whose real problem is the kitchen, not the gym.
  • Xiaomi Mi Fitness (Mi Fitness) — the companion app for Mi Bands and watches. Lightweight, no nagging, great if you already wear a Xiaomi band.
  • Huawei Health (Huawei Health) — similar idea, tied to Huawei watches; strong sleep and SpO2 tracking.

As benchmarks I also opened Strava and Apple Fitness, but neither fit a budget-first, mostly-Android routine as well. Strava is excellent for cyclists and runners who want a social feed, while Apple Fitness locks you into the Apple Watch ecosystem and a monthly fee.

How they compare

AppBest forPriceStandout featureWeakness
KeepGuided workoutsFree + subHuge video library, communityPremium plans behind paywall
Boohee HealthDiet trackingFree + subLargest local food DBBusy interface
Xiaomi Mi FitnessBand usersFreeZero friction, cleanThin workout content
Huawei HealthHealth metricsFreeSleep/SpO2 detailNeeds Huawei hardware

My weekly routine on Keep

To make the test honest I built a repeatable week: three short Keep sessions (a 7-minute core, a 12-minute hiit, a 20-minute yoga), two runs logged with its map feature, and daily food logging in Boohee Health. The short sessions were the key — on tired nights the 7-minute option meant I had no excuse, and the streak counter did its job of nudging me. I kept the plan on a wall calendar too, which sounds old-fashioned but stopped me from “forgetting” on busy days. Xiaomi Mi Fitness ran silently in the background on a Mi Band I already owned, so step and sleep data never required a second thought, and the vibration alarm woke me without disturbing my partner.

What actually made me stick

Three months in, the thing that kept me consistent was not the fanciest metric, it was the lowest-friction habit. Keep’s short sessions removed decision fatigue, and the running map found safe routes near whatever hotel or friend’s place I was at. Boohee Health quietly fixed my biggest leak — portion size — by letting me search real local dishes instead of guessing. The wearable apps proved that you do not need a coach if a 30 USD band is already counting your steps. The habit that survived travel, sickness, and a busy work month was the seven-minute core routine, because it was too small to skip.

One more honest note: the Mi Band’s step count was within about 5 percent of a manual count on walks, and its sleep stages roughly matched how tired I felt. You should not treat any consumer wearable as medical-grade, but for building a habit the feedback loop is what matters, not lab accuracy.

What made me quit an app

I deleted two apps during the test, and the reasons were instructive. The first had a genuinely good workout library but pushed a full-screen upsell after every session; being sold to four times a week wears you down and I started avoiding opening it. The second was a global tracker that wanted a subscription before it would show a weekly summary, which meant the free tier was a demo rather than a product. Neither was bad on paper, but both added friction at exactly the moment when consistency is fragile.

The apps I kept had one thing in common: the free tier was complete enough to use forever. Keep’s short sessions, Boohee Health’s food logging, and the Xiaomi band app’s step and sleep view all work without paying, which means the habit never depends on a card on file. That is the real test of a fitness app, not its feature list.

Building a week that survives real life

A plan that only works on a perfect week is a plan you will abandon. What worked for me was a two-tier week: a non-negotiable seven-minute minimum on any day, and a full session when time allowed. The minimum is the whole trick — it is too small to skip, so the streak never breaks, and once you have started you often do more anyway. I also front-loaded the week with the hard session on a day I knew was quiet, and left yoga or a walk for the busier days.

Sleep and steps came free from a Xiaomi Mi Band I already owned, and simply seeing the number nudged me more than any notification. If you do not have a wearable, your phone’s built-in step counter covers most of the value for nothing.

Do you need a subscription

Start free and stay free until a specific feature is the thing blocking you. Subscription plans in this category mostly sell three things: longer structured programs, advanced metrics, and video variety. If you are a beginner, none of that is your bottleneck — showing up is. The honest sequence is to run the free tier for a full month, note precisely what you reached for that was locked, and pay only if that gap actually cost you training sessions. For most people the free tiers of Keep and Boohee Health plus a cheap band cover the whole habit.

Privacy and data

Fitness data is sensitive: it implies where you live, when you are home, and how healthy you are. Read the privacy section before you link payment or turn on continuous location, and use a dedicated email for sign-up. I keep location on only during logged runs and leave it off otherwise, which still gives me route maps without broadcasting my address every hour. If an app asks for contacts or background location it does not need, deny it and see whether anything actually breaks. Checking the permission list once a month takes a minute and is worth it.

Which app is right for you

Choose based on your actual failure mode. If you struggle to start, pick Keep — the short guided sessions remove the decision. If your diet is the real problem, pair it with Boohee Health and log honestly for two weeks before changing anything. If you already wear a Xiaomi or Huawei band, their free companion apps give you step, sleep, and heart-rate feedback with no extra cost and no nagging. If you cycle or run competitively and want a social feed, a global platform earns its subscription — but that is a different need from building a habit, and most people confuse the two.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Keep and Boohee Health are genuinely free to start and deep enough to never need a paid app.
  • Chinese food databases beat global apps for anyone eating local meals.
  • Xiaomi and Huawei apps are free forever with their hardware.

Cons

  • Keep’s best plans sit behind a subscription.
  • Boohee Health’s interface buries features under tabs.
  • Huawei and Xiaomi apps are weak without their own wearables.

Buying advice

If you want coaching and variety, start with Keep — it is free and the Chinese-made leader here. Pair it with Boohee Health for diet and you cover 90 percent of what most people need. Only buy a wearable if you will wear it; a Xiaomi Mi Band at a low price is the sensible entry, and its app costs nothing. Skip the international subscriptions unless you specifically need their social or route-sharing features. Try the free tier for a month before paying for anything, and set one non-negotiable daily minimum so the habit forms first.

FAQ

Can I use Keep without understanding Chinese? Mostly yes. The core workouts have icons and rep counts, and the app supports an English interface now. The community posts are Chinese, but you can ignore them.

Is the food database useful outside China? Boohee Health is strongest for Chinese dishes. For Western groceries you may prefer a global tracker, though Keep’s logging is decent either way.

Do these apps sell my health data? Read the privacy section before linking payment. The free tier works without handing over much; I kept location off except during runs, and used a throwaway email for sign-up.

Disclosure: if you order through our link, TechMinds may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.